Tiffany Medicinehorse was taken into custody without incident for motor vehicle theft, criminal endangerment, fleeing as well as an outstanding warrant.
Police in Conewango, New York tried to pull 17-year old Lewis D. Hostetler over on Monday, after they noticed he was operating his horse and buggy with a open container of beer in hand.
At which point the Amish teen showed a great deal of faith in his horse and led the police on a rare medium-speed horse and buggy chase.